Jamie Luoto
Medium: oil on linen
Censored by: Instagram/Meta
Was there a notification of removal or downranking, and if so what was the reason given?: I received messages in my notifications that my content had been removed.
What date was your artwork removed or downranked?: April 23, 2025 - The post lasted for 2 hours before being removed.
Were you given an opportunity to appeal? If so, did you appeal, and if so, what was the response?: Yes, I did appeal. The automated system rejected my appeal citing: "Your post didn't follow our guidelines on nudity or sexual activity" and "Your story didn't follow our guidelines on adult sexual solicitation". Additionally, Meta's verified support responded unhelpfully by providing copied and pasted community guidelines that didn't address the actual issue raised.
What consequences have you faced as a result of the downranking or removal? Please describe in detail.: A Meta verified support agent explicitly told me my account was "lightly punished" for appealing their decision, which I thought was my right to do. In practice that punishment was a 3 day loss of direct messaging, twice. Additionally, my account was labeled as ineligible to be shown to non-followers, and my content was excluded from places like explore, search, suggested users, reels, and feed recommendations. This lasted for several months. Long term, Meta won't let me share my website URL directly. I suspect my account is flagged behind the scenes; over the last decade or so, I have experienced consistent throttling from their shadowbanning practices and heightened sensitivity around my artwork.
Please write any additional comments.: I took GREAT CARE TO CENSOR the painting before posting, covering the nipple and genitals with large black blocks, to comply with their guideline (specifically sexually suggestive, as nudity is "allowed" in paintings). I NEVER shared an uncensored version of my painting. Additionally, my account was set to 18+ per Meta's recommendation and I paid for the basic verified user account to help myself avoid issues. My painting was professionally presented with a contextualizing excerpt from an essay. The reception was incredible and positive. The post lasted all of 2 hours before it was taken down.