Charise Isis

Medium: photography.

Censored by: META

Was there a notification of removal or downranking, and if so what was the reason given?: Facebook has removed both of my personal profiles and my project’s Instagram account, claiming violations of community standards. However, the only images I share are mastectomy photographs, which are explicitly permitted under Facebook’s own guidelines. This removal has effectively cut off my nonprofit project from its fundraising lifeline—our page is directly linked to our bank/PayPal account—and it is also the primary way I communicate with photo-subjects and supporters. The loss is devastating to both our operations and the vulnerable community we serve.

What date was your artwork removed or downranked?: August 15, 2025

Were you given an opportunity to appeal? If so, did you appeal, and if so, what was the response?: “Yes. The appeal process required me to submit a video of my face, which I did, but it was rejected. I was told I had violated community standards and that my page would be permanently deleted. I still have one Instagram page active, and I even enrolled in Meta Verified specifically so I could access real support from a person, but despite this, I have received no assistance. I remain locked out of all of my accounts.

What consequences have you faced as a result of the downranking or removal? Please describe in detail.: I began this project in 2009, and with these removals I have lost an irreplaceable archive of conversations with the women who have participated, many of whom have since passed away. Facebook was my primary means of communication with subjects and audience alike, through both my personal page and my project page. Now I have NO access to my nonprofit page, which currently exists without an administrator, even though it is directly tied to my nonprofit’s bank account. This disruption comes at the worst possible moment... just as I should be ramping up critical fundraising and awareness for Breast Cancer Awareness Month. Instead, I am cut off from my community, my donors, and my work. The impact is devastating and urgent.

Please write any additional comments.: Community Harm: This isn’t only a personal loss, by removing my accounts, Facebook has severed a vital line of support for breast cancer survivors, many of whom rely on these images and stories to feel seen, connected, and empowered.

Violation of Their Own Standards: The content in question,mastectomy photographs is specifically listed as permitted within Facebook’s community standards. My removal reflects inconsistent and discriminatory enforcement that silences a vulnerable population.

Nonprofit Consequences: As a registered nonprofit, our ability to raise funds is now paralyzed. Donations are down at the exact time awareness and support should be peaking, undermining our mission and survival.

Emotional/Archival Loss: The deletion of my personal accounts has erased years of deeply personal conversations with participants, including women who are no longer alive. This is an irreplaceable cultural and historical record of resilience and survival. Please note: The images I uploaded were a random selection of the images that I post... not necessarily the ones that triggered the post... I think it is just more a result of posting these types of images often and being frozen out often..

Website:: http://www.the-grace-project.org

Previous
Previous

Jamie Luoto

Next
Next

Paul Roustan